Quality teaching modules: Applying the development cycle to demonstrate proficiency against the Standards

headshot-3aii
Module 3a

How to set goals and reflect on your practice

Overview

In Module 3a we will look at how reflection and goal setting can lead to improved student outcomes. After completing this professional learning, you should be able to:

  • Understand the importance of reflection
  • Identify and evaluate examples of reflection in your practice and context
  • Demonstrate different ways to reflect
  • Plan and evaluate SMART goals

Estimated duration

75 - 90 minutes

How to use this web page

You can work through the learning on the page or download to complete offline. The download will capture any text you have entered on the page so you can save your answers.

Work through the learning below then Print to PDF. The download will capture any text you have entered on the page. Alternatively download as Microsoft Word.

Download as Microsoft Word Print as PDF

Let’s begin

Reflection can be a formal or informal learning experience that improves an individual’s professional practice and an education setting’s collective effectiveness.

Goal setting is a structured activity that will help you achieve planned and specific outcomes.

Both reflection and goal setting encourage evaluative thinking and play an important role in growth and development.

The importance of reflection

Learning environments move at a rapid pace, and it can be challenging to find time to reflect on the impact of your teaching practice. However, taking time for reflection can be an effective form of professional learning for teachers — stopping to consider learning sequences or new initiatives, evaluating what has been successful and what changes need to be made. Learning from practice and contributing to a culture of improvement benefits teachers, leaders and students.

Watch the Reflections on Teaching and Learning Video below

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XvYZ4jcNOCE

Video notes

Further reading How-to reflection guide

Attributes of self-reflection

American philosopher and teacher John Dewey described three attributes that support reflective practice. Having these attributes in the front of your mind can assist in reflection.

Wholeheartedness: a deep commitment to learning.

Responsibility: understanding that you are responsible for your teaching practice and its impact.

Open-mindedness: the ability to learn and see areas for personal and professional growth.

The four lenses

Stephen Brookfield, leading scholar on critical and creative thinking, offers four lenses that can help you reflect on your practice from different perspectives.

  1. The autobiographical
    Reflecting on your own experiences and pedagogical choices.
  2. The learner
    Considering learner perceptions and experiences; through learner perception surveys, formative or summative assessment and other observations.
  3. Colleagues
    Enabling shared experiences, which can be informal discussions or formalised through peer observation.
  4. Theoretical literature
    Undertaking reading, professional learning and research.
Reflection activity

Look at the matrix of reflective practices and identify which ones are in current use in your education setting.

The autobiographical

The learner

Colleagues

Theoretical literature

Weekly reflection journal

Conducting student/learner surveys

Mentor/coaching relationships

Reading academic journals

Self-reflection processes during teaching evaluations

Using on the go feedback tools

Peer teaching/ team teaching

Conducting action research

Professional portfolios

Community feedback tools and opportunities

High quality reflective professional conversations

Finding relevant case studies

Is there one lens you’d like to make more room for, or one you’d like to improve in your practice? How will you do this?

Choose a practice above that you are already doing and gather evidence that demonstrates this practice. Evaluate your self-reflection below.

Selected reflective practice

Wholeheartedness: Do you commit to this practice regularly? Where in the content of your reflection can you find references to planning and monitoring your own learning?

Responsibility: How does your reflection critically reflect your impact? Are there opportunities to identity and celebrate effective practice?

Open-mindedness: Are the areas for improvement or review clear and explicit? How does this practice help identify opportunities for professional growth?

The importance of goal setting

What is goal setting?

An education setting’s performance and development process offers an opportunity for teachers to engage in targeted development focused on priority areas for themselves, their setting and sector. Setting goals as part of the performance and development process ensures improvements in practice are focused, challenging, and aligned to professional need and context.

Many education systems and sectors in Australia have their own specific performance and development processes that incorporate goal setting and professional learning plans. If you are unsure about your own context, reach out to a colleague or leader and ask what processes are in place. The information in this section has been designed to complement or supplement your practice, inviting you to consider and apply what is relevant to you.

How to set goals effectively

The most effective performance seems to result when goals are specific and challenging, when they are used to evaluate performance and linked to feedback on results, and create commitment and acceptance (Lunenburg, 2011).

This section takes you through a five step approach in your goal setting.

Step 1: Identify opportunities for reflection

Goal setting starts with reflection on practice to identify:

  • strengths
  • areas for development
  • aspirations.
Reflection activities

Reflecting on practice

  • Evaluate your teaching practice using a SWOT analysis or in accordance with the Standards using the Teacher Self-Assessment Tool.
  • Put a critical lens on the biases and assumptions you bring to your practice and how you navigate cross-cultural communications and relationships. Use the intercultural learning self-reflection tool for guidance.
  • Consider feedback from previous Performance and Development reviews

Reflecting on setting

  • Review your education settings’ goals and priorities. This can be done by reading annual reports, vision and mission statements and/or strategic plans.
  • Consider feedback from leaders, peers, parents and learners. Hear from a diverse range of people to challenge your own biases and assumptions.
  • Evaluate formal feedback such as observations, surveys and student achievement results.

Reflecting on system/sector

  • Research your system/sector priorities and initiatives.
  • Compare your performance and development reviews with the policies in your context. Consider the connection between the two perspectives. Do your goals mirror what is needed on a systemic level? How can you ensure your goals and practice embed system/sector policies?
  • Learn from peers by researching high performing teachers and strategies. Determine which aspects of practice you admire and how this can impact on your own teaching/leading by changing your practice.
Activity

Complete at least one reflection from the ‘Reflecting on practice’ above and answer the questions below. Ensure that you are including evidence in your answers.

What are my strengths? (example: I know that one of my strengths is developing relationships with students because of the feedback written in student journals. Gian wrote ‘I went to Miss Otero when I had a fight with my friend to help sort it out’).

What are my areas for development?

What are my aspirations?

Step 2: Turn reflections into goals

It is important to develop a mindset of reflection as you work to further yourself as a professional to improve your individual practice, the practice of others and that of the teaching profession to have the greatest positive impact for learners.

To turn reflective thinking into goals you need to consider the wider context. By looking at yourself as a learner in the context of competing priorities around you, there is a greater chance of planning and achieving relevant goals. Look through your answers from the previous tasks and consider the following.

What would most impact learning, engagement and wellbeing of all your learners?

How can you integrate professional interests with education setting priorities and community needs?

Are there opportunities to align with system/sector policies and initiatives?

How can you foster high-expectation relationships with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students and what you can achieve together? What should my current priority be for continual development of my culturally responsive practices?

How do you see yourself continuing to grow in proficiency across the career stages in the Standards?

Selecting a critical friend

In addition to reflecting on your own teaching philosophy and practice, establishing a critical friend and developing this relationship will give you a different perspective. A trusted colleague, mentor or leader is someone who can be with you on the journey to help you develop and grow and continually improve your professional practice.

A critical friend is:

a trusted person who asks provocative questions, provides data to be examined through another lens, and offers critiques of a person's work as a friend. A critical friend takes the time to fully understand the context of the work presented and the outcomes that the person or group is working toward. The friend is an advocate for the success of that work (Costa & Kallick 1993 p. 50).

To select a critical friend, consider your networks, both within and external to your education setting. You may have multiple critical friends who can help you to improve different aspects of your practice.

Some examples include: a curriculum leader, principal, or professional association network member, leaders of local Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander organisations, and colleagues from other education settings.

Professional conversation

Discussing your reflections with your critical friend can help identify aspects of practice you may not have considered and to clarify your developmental needs. Based on this review of your reflections, and any instructions from your education setting, draft a small number of goals that are challenging but achievable.

See the example below for how reflections can lead to a draft goal. Note the two reflections in grey that may inform another goal in this cycle or a future cycle.

See how reflections can lead to a draft goal

Step 3: Create SMART goals

Formulating SMART goals ensures your goals are clear to follow and achieve.

Specific: formulated in a way that you and others understand what is to be achieved. Think of the impact the goal should have and find a way to word the impact you want to have into one or two sentences.

Measurable: it should be possible to tell at any point in time if the goal has been achieved or not. The goal will clearly link to the types of evidence collected throughout the review period.

Achievable: challenging but realistic. If a goal is not challenging enough then find a way to extend the expectation or shorten the timeframe. If the goal is not realistic, break it down into smaller parts.

Relevant: the achievement of the goal will relate to the Standards you are working on and will have meaningful positive implications for your teaching practice, student outcomes and the overall goals of your education setting.

Time-phased: the time in which the goal should be achieved is clear, whether it’s a few weeks, a school term, or a year.

This SMART goal guide can be used for annual goal setting as part of the formal performance and development cycle.It can also be used for goal setting in the context of a coaching relationship or for shorter-term goal setting resulting from personal reflection, classroom observation or any other feedback.

(Note: If your education setting already has a goal setting template, then use the documents below as a reference point)

See the example filled in below.

Teacher’s name

Miss Smith

School leader’s name

Ms Borg

Review period

Term 1, 2022

Date completed

Week 2, Term 1 2022

SMART goal

Specific

What is your performance and development goal?

Improved skills in differentiating classroom activities to meet student needs

Measurable

What evidence will be used to demonstrate progression and achievement?

Student surveys and school-based assessments (see specific items in year level assessment schedule)

Achievable

What actions will you take to achieve it?

Peer observation, research, collaborative work with colleagues, leading to trialling a range of differentiated activities

Relevant

How does the goal connect to your professional growth, your education setting’s priorities, your students’ outcomes and the Standards?

I want to ensure I am meeting students’ needs. Student surveys highlighted the need for greater challenge. Appropriately challenging activities should lead to greater student achievement. This relates to Standard 1 ‘Know students and how they learn’ and Standard 3-‘Plan for and implement effective teaching and learning’.

Time-phased

When will the goal be achieved?

Within the first two terms

What support is required to achieve the goal?

Meetings with teaching and learning leader to improve understanding of strategies for differentiating tasks.

Teaching and learning leader to scaffold development of classroom activities and review planning documents.

Fill in the template below add further SMART goals as required

Teacher’s name

School leader’s name

Review period

Date completed

SMART goal

Delete this SMART goal

Specific

What is your performance and development goal?

Measurable

What evidence will be used to demonstrate progression and achievement?

Achievable

What actions will you take to achieve it?

Relevant

How does the goal connect to your professional growth, your education setting’s priorities, your students’ outcomes and the Standards?

Time-phased

When will the goal be achieved?

What support is required to achieve the goal?

+ Add another SMART goal

Step 4: Get goal agreement

Creating and agreeing your performance and development goals with your school leader/supervisor is crucial because it:

Creating and agreeing your performance and development goals

Once you have drafted your goals you could meet with a critical friend to review and revise. They can help you assess if your goals are:

  • appropriately challenging
  • meeting your development needs
  • following the SMART goal structure
  • in line with setting and sector goals and priorities.

The process could look like this:

Get a goal agreement, process could look like this

Step 5: Review goals

Regularly reflecting on your goals will help you gain an ongoing understanding into your achievement. This will help you to monitor your progress toward your goal(s), assess the appropriateness of evidence, make changes as required and prepare for your annual review. To best track your progress, you could also reflect on the types of evidence you are collecting to determine if they accurately or sufficiently demonstrate your development and impact.

Consider blocking out some time in your diary each week to allow for self-reflection as this is a useful way to refer to evidence to track progress. The structured matrix below will support the self-reflection process allowing you to move closer towards your goal achievement.

Self-reflection matrix activity

This activity will direct your thinking to evaluate the success of your goals and the next step forward. You can use it during short periods of reflection throughout the life cycle of the goal.

See here for an Exemplar.pdf

Goal

Step 1: Plan and conduct activities

Seek out activities that will support your goal, eg, observing a colleague, reading, professional learning.

Step 2: Evaluate effectiveness

After participating in the activities, assess your progress so far. What helped?

Step 3: Locate strategies and resources

Using what you know about the barriers and enablers for this goal, identify who can offer support and assistance, and if there is anything new you can try.

Step 4: Assess your performance

Determine how much progress you’ve made. If you have met your goal, are you ready for a new one?

Further reading Leaders can complete the Leadership reflection tool

Self-reflection on-the-go

Below is a template for a pocket-sized card that allows for quick reference of your goals and self-reflection. Capture each goal in a couple of words and note them on the left side. Then print, fold and laminate the card for easy reference.

Download pocketbook template

Download pocketbook-sized template as pictured above

Next steps

Move forward to:

Alternatively, return to the